Effective practices and partial knowledge
negotiations around the “cholesterol hypothesis”
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.52712/issn.1850-0013-682Keywords:
coproduction, cholesterol, margarine, practicesAbstract
Attempts to relate high cholesterol to the risks associated with cardiovascular disease date back to 1916. Since 1950, intensive clinical and epidemiological studies have sought evidence for this relationship. The “cholesterol hypothesis”, far from being accepted, enjoyed not only great debate during the 1950’s, but also great amounts of attention from the public. The importance gained by nutritional ideas was essential to establish a relation between cholesterol acquired through diet with high blood cholesterol and an increase of the risks associated with cardiovascular disease. In this context, the appearance on the U.S. market of a margarine based on vegetable polyunsaturated fatty acids that reduces cholesterol, and the hypothesis that high cholesterol is a risk factor for developing heart disease, are an example of the complex relationship between scientific research, food industry and consumers in this process. All of them participate in a process of co-production of knowledge about cholesterol, diet and prevention of coronary heart disease.
Downloads
References
BALL, R. A. y LILLY, J. R. (1982): “The Menace of Margarine: The Rise and Fall of a Social Problem”, Social Problems, vol. 29, nº 5, pp. 488-98.
BECH-LARSEN, T. y GRUNERT, K. G. (2003): “The perceived healthiness of functional foods. A conjoint study of Danish, Finnish and American consumers’ perception of functional foods”, Appetite, vol. 40, pp. 9-14.
BECH-LARSEN, T. y SCHOLDERER, J. (2007): “Functional Foods in Europe: consumer, research, market experiences and regulatory aspects”, Trends in Food Science and Technology, vol. 18, pp. 231-34.
CALLON, M. (1987): “Society in the making: the study of technology as a tool for sociological analysis”, en The Social Construction of Technological Systems: New Directions in the Sociology and History of Technology, ed. W.E. Bijker, T.P. Hughes, y T.J. Pinch, Cambridge, MIT Press, pp. 83-103.
CHEN, N. N. (2009): Food, Medicine, and the Quest for Good Health, New York, Columbia University Press.
CLARK, P. (1983): “The Marketing of Margarine”, comunicación presentada en el Seminario: Marketing and Advertising in the Twentieth Century,el 6 de mayo de 1983 en la Polytechnic of Central London, Londres, Reino Unido.
CLARKE, A. E., SHIM, J. K., MAMO, L., FOSKET, J. R. y FISHMAN, J. R. (2003): “Biomedicalization: Technoscientific Transformations of Health, Illness, and U.S. Biomedicine”, American Sociological Review, vol. 68, nº 2, pp.161-94.
COLLINS, H. y PINCH, T. (1982): Frames of Meaning: the social construction of extraordinary science, Londres, Routledge.
CONSTANCE, C. (2009): “The good and the bad: what researchers have learned about dietary cholesterol, lipid management and cardiovascular disease risk since the Harvard Egg Study”, International Journal of Clinical Practice,vol. 63, nº 163, pp. 9-14.
COONS, C. M. (1959): “Fats and Fatty Acids”, Yearbook of Agriculture 1959, Agricultural Research Service, National Agricultural Library.
DUPRAO, R. (1999): “‘If It’s Yellow, It Must be Butter’: Margarine Regulation in North America Since 1886”, The Journal of Economic History ,vol. 59, nº 2, pp. 353-71.
EPSTEIN, Steven (2007): Inclusion. The politics of difference in medical research, Chicago, The University of Chicago Press.
EUFIC (2011), en www.eufic.org/, consultado el1º de febrero de 2011.
FINKING, G. y HANKE, H. (1997): “Nikolaj Nikolajewitsch Anitschkow (1885-1964) established the cholesterol-fed rabbit as a model for atherosclerosis research”, Atherosclerosis,vol.135, nº 1, pp. 1-7.
Fundación Española del Corazón, (2011): en www.fundaciondelcorazon.com, constulado el1º de febrero de 2011.
GARRETY, K. (1997): “Social Worlds, Actor-Networks and Controversy: The Case of Cholesterol, Dietary Fat and Heart Disease”, Social Studies of Science,vol. 27, nº 5, pp. 727-73.
GARRETY, K. (2006): “Dietary Policy, controversy and Proof: Doing something versus waiting for the definitve evidence”, Faculty of Commerce Papers, ro.uow.edu/commpapers/452, consultado el 1º de Julio de 2010.
GONZÁLEZ GARCÍA, M. e IBÁÑEZ MARTÍN, R. (2008): “Conocer, creer y comprar: el papel del conocimiento científico en las actitudes hacia los alimentos funcionales y el medio ambiente”, en J. A. López Cerezo y F. J. Gómez González (eds.): Apropiación Social de la Ciencia, Madrid, Biblioteca Nueva, pp. 115-133
.
GREENE, Jeremy (2007): Prescribing by Numbers. Drugs and the definition of disease,Baltimore, John Hopkins University Press.
GREENHALGH, T. y WESSELY, S. (2004): “Health for me: a sociocultural analysis of healthism in the middle classes”, British Medical Bulletin,vol. 69, pp.197-213.
GRUNDY, S. M., CLEEMAN, J. I., MERZ, N. B., BREWERR Jr, H. B., CLARK L. T., HUNNINGHAKE, D. B., PASTERNAK, R. C., SMITH Jr, S. C., STONE, N. J. (2004): “Implications of Recent Clinical Trials for the National Cholesterol Education Program Adult Treatment Panel III Guidelines”, Circulatio,vol. 110, pp. 227-239.
GUSTON, D. H. (2001): “Boundary Organizations in Environmental Policy and Science: An Introduction”, Science, Technology and Human Values,vol. 26, nº 4, pp. 399-408.
HEASMAN, M. y MELLENTIN, J. (2001): The functional foods revolution: healthy people, healthy profits?,Londres, Earthscan Publications.
HEINECKE, J. (2011): “HDL and cardiovascular disease risk - Time for a new approach?”, New England Journal of Medecine,vol. 364, pp. 170-171.
HELFAND, M., BUCKLEY, D. I., FREEMAN, M., FU, R., ROGERS, K., FLEMING, C., HUMPHREY, L.L. (2009): “Emerging Risk Factors for Coronary Heart Disease: A Summary of Systematic Reviews Conducted for the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force”, Annals of Internal Medicine,vol. 151, pp. 496-507.
HOOPER, L., SUMERBELL, C. D., HIGGINS, J. P. T., THOMPSON, R. L., CAPPS, N. E., SMITH, G. D., RIEMERSMA, R. A., EBRAHIM, S. (2001): “Dietary fat intake and prevention of cardiovascular disease: systematic review”, BMJ,vol. 322, pp. 757-63.
HU, F. B., STAMPFER, M. J., RIMM, E. B., MANSON, J. E., ASCHERIO, A., COLDITZ, G. A., ROSNER, B. A., SPIEGELMAN, D., SPEIZER, F. E., SACKS, F. M., HENNEKENS, C. H. y WILLETT, W. C. (1999): “A Prospective Study of Egg Consumption and Risk of Cardiovascular Disease in Men and Women”, JAMA, vol. 281, nº 15, pp. 1387-1394.
HUNT, C. L. (1916): “Food For Young Children”, Farmer’s Bulletin, vol. 717 (21), Washington, U.S. Department of Agriculture.
HUNT, C. L. y ATWATER, H. W. (1916): “How to select foods”, Farmer’s Bulletin,808 (14), Washington, U.S. Department of Agriculture.
IBÁÑEZ MARTÍN, R. y GONZÁLEZ GARCÍA, M. (2010): “Una alimentación de cuidado: la biomedicalización y la persistencia de la performatividad de género en la comercialización de los alimentos funcionales”, Cuadernos KÓRE, vol. 1 nº 3, Invierno.
IBÁÑEZ MARTÍN, R. y SANTORO, P. (2011): Elecciones inciertas en tiempos inciertos: el ‘paciente informado’en el almacenamiento de células troncales de cordón umbilical y los alimentos funcionales,aceptado para su publicación.
JASANOFF, Sheila (1996): “Beyond Epistemology: Relativism and Engagement in the Politics of Science”, Social Studies of Science, vol. 26, pp. 393-418.
JASANOFF, Sheila (2004): “The Idiom of co-production”, en S. Jasanoff (ed.): States of Knowledge. The co-production of science and social order,Londres, Routledge.
JASANOFF, Sheila (2005): Designs on Nature: Science and Democracy in Europe and the United States, Oxford, Princeton University Press.
JOLLIFFE, N., SEYMOUR H. R. y MOROTN, A. (1959): “The Anti-Coronary Club; Including a Discussion of the Effects of a Prudent Diet on the Serum Cholesterol Level of Middle-Aged Men”, The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,vol. 7, pp. 451-461.
JOLLIFFE, N., ETHEL M., RUDENSEY, F., SIMON, M. y FAULKNER, A. (1961): “Dietary Control of Serum Cholesterol in Clinical Practice”, Circulation, vol. 24, pp. 1415-1421.
JONES, P. J. H. (2009): “Dietary cholesterol and the risk of cardiovascular disease in patients: a review of the Harvard Egg Study and other data”, International Journal of Clinical Practice,vol. 63, nº 163, pp. 1-8.
KEYS, A. (1953): “Prediction and possible prevention of coronary disease”, American Journal of Public Health,vol. 43, pp. 1399-1407.
KEYS, A., MIENOTTI, A., KARVONEN, M. J., ARAVANIS, C., BLACKBURN, H., BUZINA, R., DJORDJEVIC, B. S., DONTAS, A. S., FIDANZA, F., KEYS, M. H., KROMHOUT, D., NEDELJKOVIC, S., PUNSAR, S., SECCARECCIA, F. y TOSHIMA, H. (1986): “The Diet and 15-Year death rate in the Seven Countries Study”, American Journal of Epidemiology,vol. 124, nº 6, pp. 903-915.
LATOUR, B. (1987): Science in Action,Cambridge, Harvard University Press.
LATOUR, B. (1993): Nunca fuimos modernos. Ensayo de antropología simétrica, traducción de Victor Goldstein, Buenos Aires, Siglo XXI.
MACKENZIE, D. (1990): Inventing Accuracy: a Historical Sociology of Nuclear Missile Guidance. Cambridge, MIT Press.
MENTE, A., KONING, L., SHANNON, H. S. y ANNAND, S. S. (2009): ASystematic Review of the Evidence Supporting a Causal Link Between Dietary Factors and Coronary Heart Disease,Archives of Internal Medicine, vol. 169, nº 7, pp. 659-669.
MILLER, G. P. (1989): “Public Choice at the Dawn of the Special Interest State: The Story of Butter and Margarine”, California Law Review,vol. 77, pp. 83-113.
MILLER, C. (2001): “Hybrid Management: Boundary Organizations, Science Policy and Enviromental Governance in the Climate Regime”, Science, Technology and Human Values,vol. 26, nº 4, pp. 478-500.
MOL, A. (2008): The logic of care. Health and the problem of patient choice,Londres, Routledge.
NESTLE, M. y PORTER, D. V. (1990): “Evolution of Federal Dietary Guidance Policy: From food adequacy to Chronic Disease Prevention”, CADUCEUS, AHumanities Journal for Medicine and the Health Sciences,vol. 2, pp. 43-67.
NESTLE, M. (1993): “Dietary advice for the 1990s: The political history of the Food Guide Pyramid”, CADUCEUS, AHumanities Journal for Medicine and the Health Sciences,vol. 9, nº 3, pp. 136-153.
NESTLE, M. (2002): Food politics. How the food industry influences nutrition and health, Berkeley, University of California Press.
NIVA, M. (2007): “All foods affect health: Understandings of functional foods and healthy eating among health-oriented Finns”, Appetite,vol. 48, nº 3, pp. 384-93.
OGDEN, J. (1998): Health Psychology, a Textbook, Trowbridge, Open University Press.
ORDOVAS, J. M. (2005): “Diet-heart hypothesis: will diversity bring reconciliation?”, American Journal of Clinic Nutrition,vol. 82, nº 5, pp. 919-20.
ORTEGA, R. M., PALENCIA, A. y LÓPEZ SOBALER, A. M. (2006): “Improvement of cholesterol levels and reduction of cardiovascular risk via the consumption of phytosterols”, British Journal of Nutrition,vol. 96, Supplement S1, pp. S89-S93.
PAPPALARDO, J. K. y JONES, D. (2000): “Regulating commercial speech in a dynamic environment: Forty years of margarine and oil advertising before the NLEA”, Journal of Public Policy and Marketing,vol. 19, nº 1, pp. 74-90.
PAVONE, V. (2007): “Biotecnologías y cambio social: ¿derecho a la salud o derecho a estar sanos?”, Documentos de Trabajo, Madrid, CSIC, Unidad de Políticas Comparadas.
PLAZA PÉREZ, I., VILLAR ÁLVAREZ, F., MATA LÓPEZ, P., PÉREZ JIMÉNEZ, F., MAIQUEZ GALÁN, A., CASASNOVAS LENGUAS, J. A., BANEGAS BANEGAS, J. R., ABADAL, T., RODRÍGUEZ ARTALEJO, F. y GIL LÓPEZ, E. (2000): “Control de la colesterolemia en España, 2000. Un instrumento para la prevención cardiovascular”, Revista Española de Cardiología,vol. 53, pp. 815-837.
RAVNSKOV, U. (1998): “The Questionable Role of Saturated and Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids in Cardiovascular Disease - Diet and reinfarction trial (DART)”, Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, vol. 51, nº 6, pp. 443-60.
RAVNSKOV, U. (2001): “Fat myths and cardiovascular disease”, BMJ, vol. 322, pp. 757-763.
RAVNSKOV, U. y MCCULLY, K. S. (2009): “Vulnerable Plaque Formation from Obstruction of Vasa Vasorum by Homocysteinylated and Oxidized Lipoprotein Aggregates Complexed with Microbial Remnants and LDL Autoantibodies”, Annals of Clinical & Laboratory Science, vol. 39, nº 1, pp. 3-16.
SCIENCE NEWS-LETTER (1958): “In Science Fields”, The Science News-Letter,vol. 74, nº 7, pp. 104-05.
SCRINIS, G. (2002): “Sorry, Marge”, Meanjin,vol. 61, nº 4, pp. 108-116.
SCRINIS, G. (2008a): “On the Ideology of Nutritionism”, Gastronomica,vol. 8, nº 1, pp. 39-49.
SCRINIS, G. (2008b): “Functional foods or functionally marketed foods? A critique of, and alternatives to, the category of ‘functional foods’”, Public Health Nutrition,vol. 11, nº 5, pp. 541-545.
SIRO, I., KAPOLNA, E., KAPORLNA, B. y LUGASI, A. (2008): “Functional food. Product development, marketing and consumer acceptance - A review”, Appetite,vol. 51, nº 3, pp. 456-67.
SMITH, L. y HULL, D. (1959): “Trends in fats and oils consumption, 1953-1957”, Journal of the American Oil Chemists’Society,vol. 36, nº 1, pp. a8-a13.
SWELL, L. SCHOOLS, P. E., y TREADWELL, C.R. (1962): “Family Diet Pattern for Lowering the Serum Cholesterol Level”, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,vol. 11, pp. 102-108.
TIME MAGAZINE (1954): “From the Heart”, 19 de abril de 1954.
TIME MAGAZINE (1957): “Fats and the Arteries”, 26 de agosto de 1957.
TIME MAGAZINE (1957b): “Fats and Facts”, 30 de marzo de 1957.
TIME MAGAZINE (1957c): “Oil for Troubled Arteries”, 1º de julio de 1957.
TIME MAGAZINE (1960): “Cutting the Cholesterol”, 6 de junio de 1960.
TIME MAGAZINE (1961): “The Fat of the Land”, 13 de enero de 1961.
TIME MAGAZINE (1969): “To save the heart. Diet by Decree?”, 10 de enero de 1969.
USDA (1946): “National Food Guide”, AIS-53, USDA, National Agricultural Library.
USDA (1956): “Essentials of an Adequate Diet”. Agriculture Information Bulletin, 160, Agricultural Research Service.National Agricultural Library.
VOLK, M. (2007): “An examination of the evidence supporting the association of dietary cholesterol and saturated fats with serum cholesterol and development of coronary heart disease”, Alternative Medicine Review, vol. 13, nº 3, pp. 228-245.
WARD, R. (2009): “Talking with your patients about dietary cholesterol, diet and nutrition: best practices for family physicians”, International Journal of Clinical Practice, vol. 63, pp. 163, 22-26.
WILLIAMS, S. J. (1998): “Health as Moral Performance: Ritual, Transgression and Taboo”, Health, vol. 2, nº 2, pp. 437-57.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 CC Attribution 4.0
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
All CTS's issues and academic articles are under a CC-BY license.
Since 2007, CTS has provided open and free access to all its contents, including the complete archive of its quarterly edition and the different products presented in its electronic platform. This decision is based on the belief that offering free access to published materials helps to build a greater and better exchange of knowledge.
In turn, for the quarterly edition, CTS allows institutional and thematic repositories, as well as personal web pages, to self-archive articles in their post-print or editorial version, immediately after the publication of the final version of each issue and under the condition that a link to the original source will be incorporated into the self-archive.
